Project · 2023

Fireplace Resurface.

Westchester · Contemporary Home · 1 Week
Finished fireplace resurface with porcelain slab in a stone look, full-height floor to ceiling
The Brief

A fireplace from another decade.

A contemporary home in Westchester, built in the nineties. The house had aged well in most places; the fireplace had not. A dated stone facing, a mantel that read more nineteen-ninety than present-day, a focal wall the owners had been avoiding looking at for years.

They'd gotten quotes to resurface the whole thing in real stone — slab-cut, custom-fabricated, installed by a specialty mason. The numbers came back well above what they wanted to spend on a single wall. They called us to ask a specific question: was there a way to get the same look for meaningfully less?

The Answer

The same look. A different material.

The honest answer was yes — but only if we were willing to spec the material differently. Real stone has one price; the look of real stone has several prices, depending on how it's made.

What we specced was a large-format porcelain slab with a natural stone finish. Porcelain is not a compromise on aesthetics — at this scale and quality, it reads as stone even at arm's length. It's a compromise on provenance and on weight. The stone quarry charges for the cut; the porcelain factory charges for the print. The visual outcome in a fireplace application is the same.

We also kept the original firebox. The internal metal frame, the flue, the hearth structure — all of it was in good condition. Nothing there needed replacing. The previous quote had assumed a full tear-out. Our scope was resurfacing only. That alone accounted for a significant portion of the cost difference.

The result: the same visual statement the owners had been quoted for, built in a week, substantially under the custom-stone number.

The Work

Before and mid-build.

Resurfacing a fireplace is deceptively demanding work. Large-format slabs are heavy, fragile, and intolerant of framing that isn't perfectly flat. The wall has to be prepped and shimmed to within a few millimeters of true before a single piece goes up, because any bow in the substrate telegraphs through the tile and shows in raking light for the life of the installation.

Original fireplace before resurface, dated stone finish and mantel
Before — the original nineties stone facing and mantel.
Fireplace mid-install, substrate preparation stage
Substrate prep — flat surface is everything.
Large-format porcelain slabs being installed on fireplace
Porcelain slabs going up — seams aligned, joints tight.
The Result

A wall that finally belongs.

Full-height stone from floor to ceiling. A single uninterrupted surface where there used to be a mantel and a shelf and a break. No visible seams between slabs in the primary sight lines — the layout was planned around where a person standing in the room would actually look. The wall reads as one piece of material, not twelve.

The owners were quoted for a fireplace redo. What they got was a focal wall that sets the tone for the room.

Finished fireplace, full-height porcelain slab, contemporary living room
Next

Have a space in mind?

Start a Conversation